/ News, Porsche / New York State Supreme Court Dismisses Porsche Lawsuit

New York State Supreme Court Dismisses Porsche Lawsuit

Linked In Share
New York State Supreme Court Dismisses Porsche Lawsuit

Thursday, December 27th, Porsche won the dismissal of the lawsuit filed by 26 hedge funds which accused the automaker of causing loses of more than $1 billion.

According to the lawsuit, filed by hedge funds including Glenhill Capital LP, David Einhorn’s Greenlight Capital LP and Chase Coleman’s Tiger Global LP proceed, Porsche has engineered a ‘massive short squeeze’ back in October 2008 by secretly buying almost all VW freely traded ordinary shares in an attempt to take over the entire company, although it publicly stated that this was not the plan.

But the moment Porsche announced it had purchased almost three-quarters of VW, shares of the German automaker immediately soared, making VW the world’s biggest company by market value. This quick increase made the hedge funds lose a lot of money after betting on a decline in the stock price. Although the 2010 case Morrison vs. National Australia Bank Ltd made the U.S. Supreme Court make it difficult to bring such cases to federal courts, the hedge funds still took their chance.

“The appeals court squarely rejected the plaintiffs’ attempt to end-run Morrison by suing in a state court,” Robert Giuffra, a partner at Sullivan & Cromwell representing Porsche, said in a phone interview.

According to the New York appeals court the hedge funds were not able to prove that Porsche’s move to buy VW has caused a ’substantial nexus’ with New York and that the case was more appropriate for Germany, since the majority of parties included in the case are not New York residents.

“Porsche met its heavy burden to establish that New York was an inconvenient forum,” the court said.

by Ana Cezara Savin (my Google+) - Friday, December 28th, 2012 - filed under News, Porsche. Image credit: .
Linked In Share
Related Articles
hedge funds lawsuit new york court Porsche vw


Discuss: New York State Supreme Court Dismisses Porsche Lawsuit

Leave a Reply















Inautonews Facebook PageInautonews RSS FeedInautonews TwitterInautonews Youtube Channel

Sign up to receive our email newsletter on your email. It's safe. No spam!

Report – Uber negotiating deal with Chinese carpooling application Dida
Report – Uber negotiating deal with Chinese carpooling application DidaIn a market dominated by two local powerhouses, Didi Dache and Kuaidi Dache, California-based Uber Technologies still believes it ...
Ferrari’s driver hierarchy already set – Fiorio
Ferrari’s driver hierarchy already set – FiorioMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Kimi Raikkonen is back. 2015 is a crucial year for the Finn, having declared his interest in racing ...
Catching Mercedes ‘not possible’ – Marko
Catching Mercedes ‘not possible’ – MarkoMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Dr Helmut Marko remains doubtful Red Bull can catch up in 2015. After Australia, the Red Bull ...
German GP demise ‘serious’ for F1 nation – Haug
German GP demise ‘serious’ for F1 nation – HaugMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Norbert Haug has lamented the demise of Germany's historic grand prix. "It does not send the right ...
Ecclestone’s criticism of Vettel wrong – Berger
Ecclestone’s criticism of Vettel wrong – BergerMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Gerhard Berger has hit back at Bernie Ecclestone, following the F1 supremo's criticism of Sebastian ...
Old chiefs deserve credit for Ferrari win – Montezemolo
Old chiefs deserve credit for Ferrari win – MontezemoloMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Luca di Montezemolo insists Ferrari's former management should not be forgotten after the fabled ...
Hamilton flags 2016 deal announcement ‘this week’
Hamilton flags 2016 deal announcement ‘this week’Mar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) Lewis Hamilton's new Mercedes deal is still inching towards the signatures, the reigning world ...
Mercedes to re-think ‘fair play’ strategies – Wolff
Mercedes to re-think ‘fair play’ strategies – WolffMar.31 (GMM/Inautonews.com) The big question after Malaysia is: has Ferrari really caught Mercedes? After Sebastian Vettel's ...
Leaked – New-gen Audi A4
Leaked – New-gen Audi A4A few images with the new generation of the Audi A4 have emerged and they are revealing part of its front fascia and the interior ...
Honda S660 Concept Edition introduced
Honda S660 Concept Edition introducedThe Honda S660 Concept Edition has been designed to celebrate the launch of the regular S660 and it is a limited-run model which ...
[VIDEO] See this Ferrari LaFerrari do donuts inside
[VIDEO] See this Ferrari LaFerrari do donuts insideDonuts and burnouts seem to be the Ferrari LaFerrari’s special and such a hypercar has been recently filmed while burning its ...
Mechanic takes BMW M4 Coupe for refill, crashes it
Mechanic takes BMW M4 Coupe for refill, crashes itA BMW mechanic has taken an M4 Coupe for a refill but he ended up crashing the performance model into a tree. A 23-year old guy ...
Recall roundup: BMW X5 for airbag problems
Recall roundup: BMW X5 for airbag problemsBMW has recently issued a recall for the X5 full-sized SUV because of a problem with its airbags. The German based automaker BMW ...
[VIDEO] Ferrari 488 GTB filming its promo
[VIDEO] Ferrari 488 GTB filming its promoThe Ferrari 488 GTB has been spotted recently on the road where it was filming its first promotional video. Ferrari has been ...
[VIDEO] Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat goes drifting
[VIDEO] Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat goes driftingA new video released onto the web is showing the impressive Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat drifting on public roads. The Dodge ...
Read more automotive news


2015 Geneva Motor Show Coverage

2016 audi a4 1
Honda S660 Concept Edition 1
bmw m4 coupe crash mechanic netherlands 1
mclaren mp4-12c crash train florida 1
mclaren 675lt spotted spain 1
Audi R8 V10 Plus Vegas Yellow 1
hyundai veloster prototype mid-engine 1
2016 Porsche Panamera Edition 1
Range Rover SVAutobiography 1
Lincoln Continental Concept 1
bmw x5 xdrive40e shanghai motor show 1
BMW_M135i_3dr

More automotive from inautonews
In a market dominated by two local powerhouses, Didi Dache and Kuaidi Dache, California-based Uber Technologies still believes it can expand its ride-sharing services, and the latest move according to an investor is to partner with another local firm - Dida Pinche. Andy Zhang, chief financial ...
read more
Inautonews Editors Section
Test Drive – Mitsubishi ASX 2.2 Diesel AT Instyle 4WD
Test Drive – Mitsubishi ASX 2.2 Diesel AT Instyle 4WD The Mitsubishi ASX can be called just about anything except for “new” and this is the word we are looking for because the company seems to have ...
Test Drive – BMW 2-Series Active Tourer 218d
Test Drive – BMW 2-Series Active Tourer 218dIn an attempt to keep production costs low and to go ahead with its times, the 2-Series Active Tourer is the first vehicle made by BMW with a ...
Test Drive: BMW 225i Active Tourer
Test Drive: BMW 225i Active TourerOne word of advice from the very beginning – if you’re a BMW purist that believes the blue-white logo has nothing in common with front wheel ...

Editors Section
Inautonews Editors Section
2012 Safest Cars list 2011 Safest Cars [Video] 2011 IIHS Safest Cars [Video] 2011 EuroNCAP Safest Cars 2010 Safest Cars [Video]

Latest in Safety Recall roundup: BMW X5 for airbag problemsBMW has recently issued a recall for the X5 full-sized SUV because of a problem with its ... Computers assist small SUVs in passing crash testsThe subcompact crossover segment is shaping up as the place to go for automakers even on the ...
Safety Section