InAutoNews InAutoNews

News

BMW CEO Calls EU CO2 Targets ‘Impossible’ at 2013 AGM

Norbert Reithofer warned shareholders that 2020’s 95g/km CO2 fleet target would require billions in investment and accused EU lawmakers of ignoring technical realities.

By Chris Wilson
BMW F30 3 Series sedan parked outdoors
BMW F30 3 Series sedan parked outdoors Shane K from Mississauga, Canada / CC BY-SA 2.0

BMW’s chief executive, Norbert Reithofer, used the company’s 2013 annual general meeting in Munich to criticise the European Union’s CO2 emissions targets as “almost impossible to meet” under current rules. Addressing shareholders, Reithofer argued that the 2020 fleet average goal of 95g CO2/km would require billions in investment, especially from German manufacturers, and described the EU’s approach as driven by “political wish-lists” rather than technical feasibility.

Reithofer’s main complaint centred on the EU’s credit system for alternative drivetrains. He pointed out that while the EU awarded a 1.5x multiplier for low-emission vehicles, China used a factor of 5 and the US a factor of 2. This, he said, put European manufacturers at a disadvantage compared to rivals in other global markets, making it harder for them to justify and recoup the costs of developing new technology.

He accused lawmakers of setting targets without proper analysis or practical testing, warning that the approach risked pushing European carmakers beyond feasible limits. “At some point, politicians will go a step too far,” Reithofer told the meeting, echoing concerns widely held among German premium brands at the time.

Why German manufacturers felt targeted

The 2020 EU regulation required manufacturers to cut average CO2 emissions from 130g/km in 2015 to 95g/km by 2020. Failure to comply would bring fines of €95 for every car sold per gram over the limit. This framework hit German brands especially hard, as their line-ups included more large-engined, higher-output models than many mass-market competitors.

BMW was not alone in its criticism. Daimler’s CEO, Dieter Zetsche, said in 2018 that his company could not guarantee it would meet the 2021 standards, calling the challenge “huge for everyone.” Fiat Chrysler’s Sergio Marchionne also acknowledged the risk of fines and the difficulty of compliance, especially as diesel sales fell after the Volkswagen emissions scandal. Diesel technology had been central to German manufacturers’ CO2 reduction strategies, but its decline forced a rapid shift to electrification and hybrids.

Alternative drivetrains and credit multipliers

The EU’s system for rewarding alternative drivetrains was a particular source of frustration for BMW. Under the 2020 rules, electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles counted towards a manufacturer’s fleet average, but the EU’s 1.5x multiplier was less generous than China’s or the US’s. Reithofer argued that this limited the incentive for European firms to accelerate electrification, especially when compared to the global competition.

  • EU: 1.5x credit for alternative drivetrains
  • US: 2x credit for alternative drivetrains
  • China: 5x credit for alternative drivetrains

Despite the criticism, manufacturers invested heavily in electrification and new drivetrain technologies in the years that followed. The pressure to comply with EU rules shaped product planning and research budgets throughout the decade, even as executives continued to warn that the targets were set without sufficient regard for technical and market realities.

More from News

Tesla Model S (2023) parked outside Motorworld Munich
News

Tesla’s Eco Credentials Questioned by Lifecycle Emissions Study

Tesla Gigafactory Shanghai assembly line with contemporary Tesla vehicles
News

Tesla’s China Sales Drop 11.9% as Exports from Giga Shanghai Surge

Front view of the Tesla Cybercab
News

Tesla Cybercab’s Grok @bot integration draws attention as robotaxi fleet faces NHTSA probe

BYD Han EV luxury saloon in a studio setting
News

BYD launches Great Han EV luxury saloon with 1,000 km range for $35,000